Assorted 'healthy' packaged foods
Nutrition August 23, 2023

10 "Healthy" Foods That Are Secretly High in Sugar

Surprising culprits in your pantry and smarter swaps.

Lisa Chen, RD

Lisa Chen, RD

Registered Dietitian

The Sugar Trap

The average American consumes 17 teaspoons of added sugar daily (CDC) - much of it hidden in foods marketed as "natural" or "wholesome".

Did You Know?

Many "low-fat" products replace fat with sugar. A single low-fat yogurt can contain more sugar than a glazed donut.

Top Offenders & Swaps

1. Flavored Yogurt

Sugar Bomb: 24g per 6oz cup (≈6 cubes)
Flavored yogurt cups

Swap: Plain Greek yogurt + fresh berries + dash of honey (≈8g total)

2. Granola

Sugar Bomb: 12g per 1/4 cup

Swap: Homemade mix with oats, nuts, and unsweetened coconut (≈1g)

3. Acai Packets

Sugar Bomb: 22g per 100g serving
Acai smoothie bowl

Swap: Frozen unsweetened acai + banana for natural sweetness

Sugar Label Decoder

Term What It Really Means
"No added sugar" May still contain fruit concentrates
"Organic cane sugar" Still sugar (just less processed)
"Light" Often means "more sugar added"

Shopping Tips

Label Tricks

  • Check serving sizes (many list unrealistically small portions)
  • Look for "sugar" in the first 3 ingredients

Smart Swaps

  • Choose whole fruit over dried fruit
  • Opt for nut butters with just nuts + salt

Get Weekly Health Hacks

Sign up for our newsletter to receive simple, actionable health tips every Monday